Rev. Father McGee, 1856 to 1857
Rev. John Stehle, 1857 to 1858
Rev. Nicholas Stehle, 1858 to 1860
Rev. John Polak, 1860 to 1862
Rev. M. Hens, 1862 to 1863
Rev. L. Lux, 1863 to 1864
Rev. M. Schwebach, 1866 to 1869
Rev. Wm. Mahany & Rev. J. Gleason, 1869 to 1870
Rev. L. Cornelius, 1871 to 1873
Rev. F. Tangauy, 1873 to 1874
Rev. Nicholas, 1874 to 1887
Rev. C. J. Alton, 1888 to 1889
Rev. E. P. Lorigan, 1889 to 1890
Rev. M. J. O'Brien, 1890 to 1893
Rev. W. J. Rice, 1893 to 1919
Rev. James C. Hogan, 1919 to 1927
Rev. George A. Casey, 1927 to 1939
Rev. John R. McGinley, 1939 to 1968
Rev. Thomas E. Mullen, 1968 to 1987
Rev. Dennis J. Lynch, 1987 to 1999
Rev. Daniel Kozlowski, 1999 to 2003
Very Rev. John Potaczek, 2003